Become an O8 Affiliate – Earn 20% commission on all sales.
Become an O8 Affiliate – Earn 20% commission on all sales.
Why the Talent Pool Seems So Shallow: A Small Business Owner's Guide to Hiring When Nobody Wants to Work
The Talent Pool Isn't Shallow. You're Just Bad at Fishing.
"Nobody wants to work anymore."
You've said it. Your business owner friends have said it. It's become the anthem of every hiring struggle since 2020.
Here's the truth: People want to work. They just don't want to work for you. Not at that rate. Not under those conditions. Not with that vague job description you wrote between client calls.
The talent pool isn't shallow. You're fishing in the wrong spot, using the wrong bait, wondering why you keep catching the same catfish.
What You're Actually Saying
When you say "nobody wants to work," you mean one of three things:
Nobody wants to work for what I'm paying. Nobody wants to work the way I need them to work. Nobody qualified is applying to my job posting.
All three are solvable. None of them are a talent shortage. They're a you problem.
The Real Shift (And Why You're Still Operating Like It's 2019)
Something did change after 2020. The power dynamic flipped. Workers figured out they had options. Remote work stopped being a perk and became a baseline expectation. Work-life balance went from nice-to-have to dealbreaker.
Your ideal candidate isn't desperate anymore. They're selective. They're evaluating you as hard as you're evaluating them. And right now? You're not passing the test.
You're still hiring like it's your dad's economy. Post a job, wait for applications, pick the best one. That worked when candidates were grateful just to be considered. It doesn't work now.
The businesses winning the hiring game aren't playing the same game you are. They're not waiting for talent to apply. They're making talent want to work for them before a position even opens.
Why Good Candidates Are Ignoring You
Your job posting is invisible. Not because it's poorly written (although … is it?), but because you have no employer brand. No presence. No reason for anyone to care about your company beyond "we have an opening."
Good candidates aren't trolling job boards hoping to stumble onto your listing. They're getting recruited. They're hearing about opportunities through their network. They're being approached by companies they already respect.
You're waiting for them to find you. They're never going to find you.
And when they do somehow land on your posting? It screams desperation. "Immediate start." "Fast-paced environment." "Wear many hats." Every red flag that signals "we're disorganized and about to burn you out."
They keep scrolling.
The Desperation Cycle (And Why It Keeps Failing)
Here's your pattern: You wait until you're drowning to hire. You need someone yesterday. You write a vague job description because you don't have time to think it through. You interview whoever applies. You hire the first person who seems competent.
Then they start. They're not as good as you hoped. They need more training than you expected. They don't have the mysterious "initiative" you wanted but never defined. Three months in, you're disappointed. They're confused. Nobody's happy.
Your conclusion: The talent pool is shallow.
Wrong conclusion. You hired from desperation, onboarded in chaos, and expected them to thrive anyway. They didn't fail. You set them up to fail.
Then you do it again. Same pattern. Same disappointment. Still blaming the talent pool.
What "Competitive Salary and Benefits" Actually Means
Nothing. It means nothing.
Every job posting says that. It's corporate wallpaper. Background noise. If your employee value proposition starts and ends with "we pay fairly and have health insurance," you're offering the bare minimum and wondering why top performers aren't excited.
Good candidates want to know: What will I learn here? Who will I become? What problem are we solving? Why does this company matter?
You're selling a transaction. They want a trajectory. That's the gap.
And no, your company culture isn't "we're like a family." Families are dysfunctional. That's not the selling point you think it is.
The Fishing Analogy Everyone Uses (But Gets Wrong)
Everyone talks about fishing in different ponds. Getting a better hook. Using the right bait. All cute. All useless if you're still just fishing.
Stop fishing. Start farming.
The companies that don't have hiring problems aren't reactive hunters scrambling when they need someone. They're cultivating relationships with talent long before they have an opening. They're building a reputation that makes people want to work there. They're creating a pipeline of candidates who are already warm when a position opens.
You can't do that with a job posting. You do that with systems, presence, and relationships. That takes time. Which is why you should have started yesterday.
What Actually Works (When You Stop Making It Harder Than It Needs to Be)
First, figure out why someone would want to work for you. Not "why they should" based on what you think is valuable. Why they actually would. What's in it for them beyond a paycheck? If you don't have a good answer, you don't have a hiring strategy. You have hope.
Second, stop writing job descriptions for imaginary people. You're not hiring a VP of Everything. You're hiring someone who can handle specific problems. Name the problems. Describe what success looks like. Skip the laundry list of requirements that screens out everyone interesting.
Third, build relationships before you need them. Go where your ideal candidates are. Industry groups. Online communities. Conferences. Have conversations. Build a reputation. Make your company known for something other than "we're hiring (again)."
Fourth, make your hiring process not suck. Fast responses. Clear communication. Respect for people's time. Sad reality: the bar is low here. You can clear it just by treating candidates like humans instead of applicants.
Fifth, hire before you're desperate. We know. You can't afford it until you need it. You also can't afford to keep hiring badly, training poorly, losing people, and starting over. Do the actual math. Proactive hiring is cheaper than crisis hiring. Every time.
The Pattern You Need to Break
You're stuck in a loop. Need someone, panic hire, underwhelming results, lose them or limp along disappointed, repeat. The loop doesn't break itself. You have to break it.
That means hiring differently. Earlier. More strategically. With actual systems instead of desperate job posts. It means building an employer brand that makes people want to work for you before you even have an opening.
It means accepting that hiring in today's market requires showing up differently than you did five years ago. The rules changed. You're still playing by the old ones. That's why you're losing.
The Talent Pool Isn't the Problem
It never was. The talent is out there. Smart, capable, motivated people who could help you grow. They're just not applying to your chaotic job posting written in crisis mode promising "competitive pay" and "great team culture."
They're going to companies that figured this out sooner. Companies that made it easy to say yes. Companies that built systems for attracting talent instead of just posting and praying.
You can keep blaming the talent pool. Or you can build systems that make the right people want to work for you.
One of those options scales. The other keeps you stuck.
Your call.
THE GETAWAY
Your final destination for ditching the overwhelm and stress of running a business.
Get The BRIEF
Smart plays - straight to your Inbox!
Stay Connected
Hey there, let's hang out!
